Welcome to Ep 169 of the Think UDL Podcast: Adult Literacy Lens on UDL with Caroline Brennan. Caroline Brennan is an Adult Educator at Dublin College Loughlinstown. She has just completed her research on the commonalities of UDL and Adult Literacy in Ireland and has some very helpful insights into using UDL for adult learners. In today’s episode, we will discuss the “banking model” of education and its faults, how adult literacy education challenges traditional power dynamics in the classroom, the gap between official policies such as job skills and metrics and the soft, life-changing outcomes of learning that are often not categorized. We also have an extended discussion on what to do with the overabundance of choice that can possibly be paralyzing to some students, and the ways in which traditional schooling fails students rather than students failing school.
Resources
Connect with Caroline Brennan via email: carolinebrennan@ddletbaes.ie
Exploring the Alignment Between UDL and Teaching Practices in Adult Literacy Education in Ireland
Mapping UDL to Adult Literacy Education Conceptual Framework Detail Caroline Brennan.pdf
UDL and Adult Literacy Commonalities Conceptual Framework Caroline Brennan 2026.pdf
Overview
The discussion explored how adult literacy practice can inform more relational, flexible, and learner-centered UDL in education.
Relational Teaching
- Caroline described adult literacy’s dialogical approach: tutors build trust, understand learners’ needs, and co-create curricula rather than treating UDL as a checklist or set of accommodations.
- Small class sizes support individual relationships, while higher education instructors can also build community within courses.
Policy And Choice
- UDL can fit existing curricula, but without learner feedback and accountability it may become performative or reinforce existing norms. Participants discussed the need to value confidence, critical thinking, and other life-changing outcomes alongside job skills and metrics.
- Choice should be scaffolded to learners’ capacity. Caroline suggested offering less choice for learners earlier in Bloom’s taxonomy, providing varied ways to encounter content, and testing approaches with learners. A familiar default assignment can reduce overwhelm while preserving alternatives.
Learning Differences
- Caroline cited a pilot in which 38 of 40 adult literacy students assessed were found to be dyslexic, and said Ireland’s adult literacy rate is about one in five adults. Traditional schooling can mistake learning differences for behavioral or moral failings and expect synchronous progress.
- Screening can help name learning differences, reduce self-blame, and identify useful strategies. The discussion emphasized that the system may fail learners, rather than learners failing school.
Outline
Adult Literacy and UDL
- Adult literacy uses dialogue, co-created curricula, and tutor-learner relationships to challenge the banking model.
- UDL should be foundational rather than a checklist; learner feedback and accountability help ensure inclusive practice is real.
Choice and Learning
- Educators can offer structured, scaffolded choices based on learner capacity and familiarity.
- Varied presentation and repetition support learning; choice can expand as learners build skills.
- Confidence, relationships, and life effects matter alongside employment outcomes and exam metrics.
Systemic Barriers
- The discussion cited 38 of 40 assessed students in a pilot identified as dyslexic and noted overlapping neurodivergence.
- Traditional schooling often assumes learners progress synchronously, potentially mislabeling learning differences and contributing to shame.
- Screening and accessible curriculum design can reframe the issue as an environment that failed to meet learners’ needs.
- Protect specialized and community-based literacy services from being replaced by cost-cutting interpretations of UDL.
Transcript
41:33
SUMMARY KEYWORDS
Adult literacy, UDL, Learner variability, Banking model, Power dynamics, Systemic barriers, Student agency, Neurodivergence, Dyslexia, Curriculum design, Relational approach, Educational policy, Learning process, Student confidence, Choice overload
SPEAKERS
Lillian Nave, Caroline Brennan
Lillian Nave 00:00
Welcome to Think UDL, the Universal Design for Learning podcast, where we hear from the people who are designing and implementing strategies with learner variability in mind. I’m your host Lillian Nave, and I’m interested in not just what you’re teaching, learning, guiding, and facilitating, but how you design and implement it, and why it even matters. Welcome to episode 169 of the Think UDL podcast, Adult Literacy Lens on UDL with Caroline Brennan. Caroline Brennan is an adult educator at Dublin College Loughlinstown, and she has just completed her research on the commonalities of UDL and adult literacy in Ireland, and has some very helpful insights into using UDL for adult learners. In today’s episode, we will discuss the banking model of education and its faults, how adult literacy education challenges traditional power dynamics in the classroom, the gap between official policies such as focusing on job skills and metrics, and the soft, life-changing outcomes of learning that are often not categorized, we also have an extended discussion on what to do with the overabundance of choice that can sometimes be paralyzing to some students, and the ways in which traditional schooling fails students rather than students failing school. It’s quite a nuanced discussion, and I hope you will enjoy. And I thank you so much for listening to the Think UDL podcast. I’d like to welcome Caroline Brennan. Welcome to the Think UDL podcast.
Caroline Brennan 01:57
Thank you so much for having me.
Lillian Nave 01:58
Glad to have you here. Lots of things to talk about with your fantastic research that I was very interested in, and you’ve done a really fantastic job. But before we get into that, I ask the same question to all my guests: What makes you a different kind of learner?
Caroline Brennan 02:15
I think what makes me a different kind of learner is if I have any sort of curiosity on a subject. It doesn’t matter what form it comes in. I want to know about it, so I’ll get get really into a deep dive, and I want to know the ins and outs, the ups and downs about it. But then, having said that, if there is a topic that I’m not particularly interested in, if there is a relaxed environment. If the conditions are right, if how the information is shared suits me, then I can pretty much get on board with it. Which is why I think I have such an interest in UDA.
Lillian Nave 02:52
Nice. Yes. So I’m interested in that. Let me ask a little further question. So, what is that relaxed environment? Let’s say you have little interest in something. What what what are the perfect conditions for you?
Caroline Brennan 03:06
I suppose the opposite of school. You know, if something is enforced, if something is very structured, and if it is dictatorial learning, I tend not to have such an interest in it. And but when it is more relaxed, conversational, and there is input from the group. Definitely, it tends to to draw me in a little bit more.
Lillian Nave 03:29
Excellent. Yeah, I gotcha. I if if I have maybe nothing else to do, then I’m finally going to do those things. Learn about do that thing. Go. Oh, I didn’t want to have to do this. Then I’ll do it. But I got to be pretty relaxed to do that. Yeah, very much so. Exactly. Okay. So you had a lot of connections you were making between UDL and adult literacy in Ireland. Yeah. And your I noticed that your thesis highlights how adult literacy resists FARE’s banking model of education through one-to-one provision and dialog and co-created curricula. So, what can higher education practitioners learn from this relational approach when we’re trying to implement UDL beyond checklists and just simple accommodations.
Caroline Brennan 04:24
Well, I think that’s the key thing there. You know, when you look at fur, it’s about involving the community. It is that dialogical approach and seeing where the needs of the learners are, and that is your starting point. And I think that’s really key in the approach in Ireland to adult literacy. And you know, it is formed from that grassroots volunteer movement. And you had mentioned there that that you know checklist approach. And I think you know if you are treating UDL as a box ticking exercise, you’re not really implementing UDL. You know, it isn’t just that you know that. That set of technical accommodations or reasonable accommodations, you know, for disability services, it has to be taking into account that you are going to have a diverse group of learners in your classroom, and you have to plan for that. And when you do plan for that, it means that you’re reaching everybody because when you make your materials accessible in more than one form, it means that everybody can learn in the way that suits them best. And I think it really has to be. I know UDL has a plus one approach, and I think that’s really great because we’re talking about reaching learners where they are at, but we also have to reach educators where they are at too. And I think some is always better than none, and it’s a great starting point. But when we really get into it at its core with UDL, it is a foundational approach to the curriculum, and it has to be inbuilt into that curriculum, and I think where adult literacy really kind of gets that right is the tutor learner relationship, and that is a foundational aspect to it. And without that, you’re really going nowhere. And because of that dialogical approach, because of that more social aspect to it, it means that the educator gets to know the student. Because sometimes students come into our classrooms and they don’t know what they need, and they don’t know how they learn best. But it’s through those conversations and through our experience that we can kind of glean from that the directions to go in for our learners, and really, you know, taking the time to build that trust and rapport. And I think, in particular, with adult literacy, a lot of our learners carry a lot of shame. So they might be early school leavers, or they might not have, you know, finished formal education at all. And with that, they tend to put a lot of blame on themselves, as opposed to they were failed by the system, or the system didn’t reach them, or didn’t serve them well. And so that’s really where we come in, and we really try and build up that rapport, and we we have that relational approach for that reason. But I think that can really be applied to everybody in every educational setting, and while keeping professional boundaries in place, of course. Where it is trickier for higher education professionals is the class sizes. So we would have very diverse needs in adult literacy, so our class sizes are intentionally very small, and they have to be very small to build that rapport. But there are other ways that people can, and I know one of the the UDEL considerations is about forming community and building community, and you know trying to ingrain that into how you approach teaching. And but I think a lot of institutions can sometimes farm that out to the societies, and you know that’s how people form community. But actually, I think it has to be really integrated into every class to be able to reach people and understand them, and to know how what what methodologies of sharing information and for learners for their assessments, what way they can share information that works best for them as well.
Lillian Nave 08:27
Yeah, you mentioned that some students, the adult learners, come in and they blame themselves instead of the system.
Caroline Brennan 08:34
Yes,
Lillian Nave 08:34
they don’t know what might work for them because they’ve only been in whatever the standardized system was, yeah, and it seems like that, like larger class sizes usually in that elementary or high school, yeah, and so it puts a few barriers up about how diverse you can be in your like teaching choices, or you know, you’re just because of the the size of the class, and so it seems like there’s a lot of things that are set in stone, right? Yeah, and they can’t change, and they’re not very flexible, and that seems to be what school is, right? Whatever is normal, like what is your usual, seems natural, and it’s not true. Like it’s not true that that’s the natural way we learn, but that’s just the normal or the usual way. And then they think, oh well, that’s just the way you learn, not all of the different ways you could learn. And so it seems like it’s just it’s in that relationship, that a practitioner who knows about education can say, actually, there’s actually there’s so many different ways you could learn this. It doesn’t have to be in that traditional classroom setting. It could be very experiential. It could be very relational. Could right? It could be all these different things. But nobody would know that unless they.
Caroline Brennan 10:00
That relationship, right? Very much, and I think that’s part of the problem as well. Is that a lot of people we teach the way we, or we we teach the way we have learned. Yes, and if you have come through what Freire describes as the banking model of education, where I as the teacher impart the information and you receive it like a deposit, if that has worked for you, right, then you don’t see anything wrong with that, and you don’t see why someone else might need to receive information multiple ways in different forms or express it in a different way than you might feel comfortable expressing it, or whatever the standard or norm
Lillian Nave 10:34
is. Yeah. Wow. Yes. So you’re already, I think, opening up our thinking about this, yeah, and and it’s a really good nuanced understanding too of of UDL, and so kind of moves into the next question I have, which is that you make a very incisive point that UDL tends to work within existing systems, just like we were talking about, whereas adult literacy directly challenges those power dynamics. Do you worry that UDL can sometimes be a performative business as usual if we don’t address those bigger systemic barriers?
Caroline Brennan 11:09
100%. But I think you know it really is a double-edged sword. So one of the attractive things and one of the the great things about UDL is that it is so flexible and it can fit in very seamlessly to an existing curricula, but that’s also really a downside because if it is fitting in with the existing norms, then it’s not challenging them. And I think one of the things that is so successful about adult literacy approach is that it does exist outside of the norm, and it does challenge the existing methodologies of teaching and the banking method, and that was only achieved because it was formed through volunteer work, because people could actually use what works for their learners and disregard what doesn’t. And when you’re talking about reaching marginalized learners, you really have to put that time, that effort, that energy into getting them. And once you get them in your doors, you have to do what you can to keep them there as well. So that’s why it is so learner focused. But I think you know one of the the pieces that I read as part of the research, which was as a result of listening to your podcast, was academic ableism. And with that, as I was interviewing people, you know, I was asking them this quote from this book that I have read: “What is your opinion?” And it was the quote of, you know, universal design can be a way of promising everything, you know, without necessarily delivering or while not doing a whole heap of anything. And I was actually incredibly surprised because I thought that was quite harsh, and I thought I was going in like like hyper critical. Um, but I was quite surprised at the responses to that, and how people were in agreement that there is very much potential with UDL, that it’s in the prospectus and it’s on the website and it’s in the policy that this is our method of of reaching people. But actually, without accountability and without feedback from the learners, from the people who are using the services, then there is huge potential for it to be used as a way to gloss over or to put forward that this is this amazing thing we’re doing, and it’s you know it’s inclusive and everybody is welcome. But actually, does it meet that criteria and practice, you know, and and that’s the the really tricky thing about it.
Lillian Nave 13:46
Yeah, we need to continuously have that feedback and um and be flexible, right? Absolutely. Yeah. Um, and it’s not um we oh gosh, don’t we wish it were just a checklist and we could just apply this, you know, all these little boxes, and we can do it. But I really appreciate your lens that you’re bringing, which is this adult literacy relationship part. That’s I think putting a much more refined lens as we look at UDL because it’s bringing down the size, I think, or or thinking about those relationships within the class, classroom, whatever the educational experience is, and yeah, you know, some of these things like the traditional method works for some people, absolutely doesn’t work for others, and so how do you do both, or not just both, but then another one, and another one, and another one at the same time. So,
Caroline Brennan 14:46
and I think just to kind of put it in context, in Ireland, I’m not sure about the statistics for for the US, but in Ireland, 21 of adults have issues with literacy. Now, that ranges. From you know recognizing letters, being able to say words, or it could be that they might have an issue with structuring sentences, or or you know vocabulary issues and things like that. But to have one in five people have an issue, I think speaks volumes. It shows that that the system isn’t necessarily working for huge number of people,
Lillian Nave 15:22
yeah, that is a big percentage. I don’t know in the U.S., but I know we are not doing a fantastic job. I know that, so it might be similar. I don’t know. So your research highlights a big gap between the official policies, which focus on metrics and job skills, which like we do in the United States as well, and what actually happens in the classroom, like things like building student confidence, which is so important. So, how do you think we can get the policymakers to value those things, those soft, life-changing outcomes that don’t fit neatly into an exam score,
Caroline Brennan 16:02
many different ways. Okay, oh, excellent. Okay, well, I think one of the issues is that some policymakers are disconnected from the experiences of marginalized learners, so they just might not understand their perspective or where they’re coming from. And it goes back to our previous conversation of if the system has worked for you, you don’t have that understanding of why it doesn’t work for for other people. And I think one of the key things in relation to that is actually getting those people to hear learner experiences, to hear how they’ve benefited, not just in an educational way, but how that has built their confidence and how that has impacted the rest of their lives, their interactions with their family, their interactions with their neighbors, their friends, and building their capacity to be able to do more as well, which is the key thing. And then I think we also have to question what we value as a society. Like certainly in our policy documents, there’s the All Strategy in Ireland, which focuses just on literacy. But then there’s the FET strategy, which is which is broader for for further education and training. Yes, and a lot of that has been focused purely on training for the economy. And do we really want to be reactively training for the economy, or do we want to value education in a more rounded or holistic sense? Like, I think we really kind of need to tilt that lens at a more holistic approach to education, because I think when we educate people in a broader sense that that they’re not going to be missing the media literacy. They’re not going to be missing that criticality or using their critical skills that a lot of us, including adults, seem to be missing out on, particularly nowadays. And and taking away that narrow lens of being results focused as well, you know. When we teach to test, we don’t value education. We’re focused on the result of it, and I think we also need to, as a society, value the process of learning. And it was explained to me that I actually I can’t remember who said it? I’d love to credit them for it. But if you go to the gym and you lift really heavy weights, it’s an amazing human feat, you know, because you have trained your muscles. That is a process. If you go into that same gym and you use a forklift, yes, you get the same result. Yeah, but it’s not the same thing at all. And I think we kind of need to view education in that way that the process of doing things is so important, particularly now that we have more access to information than we ever have, particularly now that we have AI that can give us results, but we are missing out on the process. That’s not to knock AI because there are plenty of things that it can do in terms of accessibility. But we also need to look at it in terms of removing that process or removing that step for people that they so badly need when they are in that educational space. And also, it’s understanding that you know there are no easy answers to complex questions. Some things do take time, you know, that we can’t just move the dial from 21% down to 7% without the funding, without the resources, without the time that it takes to get there.
Lillian Nave 19:32
You know, that answer makes me think about our what is it that we in higher education and FET, right? We have similar, like our community colleges, technical colleges in the United States. We do have a major push on results and on jobs in the economy, and and that’s and and I hear you. You’re not saying we should. That’s fine, of course, right? Of course, that’s important. But have we we’ve lost a little bit of the plot on on the other parts of that education, and what are the merits of being in a school, going through that process? You know, I’d loved your example of going to the gym, and you can lift the heavy weights, right? And then, then you become stronger. But it’s because you’ve trained your body to do it. You do it with a forklift, you’re not going to do it. Exactly. But also, it makes me think of when you’re going to the gym and you’re doing that, you’ve got this community there, and they’re cheering you on, and they’re you’re learning from them. Oh, this is how I this is how I lift the weight that way. Oh, he’s doing it this way, or she’s doing it, and then you’ve got these people, and it’s so much a social venture too. And you’re building so many things along with that strength. You’re building, you know, how you learn, and not just your strength and skills, but how you learn, how you learn with others, how you communicate with those others. So thinking about higher ed, we often are only saying it’s those results, and it’s like an education campaign we need to do again about what is what what is the purpose of higher education? Yeah, and further education. And so yes, it’s this, but also we can’t forget it’s also about this, and it’s and that’s also worthwhile, even though it’s much more ethereal, right? We can’t we can’t put it in the metric, right? Like, yeah, we need some sort of education campaign or you know, flashy signs. I don’t know
Caroline Brennan 21:37
neon lights always on light
Lillian Nave 21:39
enough. Yeah, something that will help us to to round that out because it is and and you know you see it with your learners I see it in my classrooms about just the the non the things you don’t see on an exam just the the lights turning on and their eyes and and you know I think it’s it’s trusting the educators as well, you know that that you know there’s so much more that goes on in the classroom or in educational spaces than what we see in those results. Yeah, and it’s trusting that the educator is there, that they’re focused on the learners, that they are enacting those benefits, you know that they’re facilitating those benefits, as opposed to just teaching to test, as opposed
Caroline Brennan 22:30
to just focusing on metrics.
Lillian Nave 22:31
Yeah, absolutely. Oh, yeah, this is exactly the kind of things I’m interested in, and and what I see every day, and so many of that. So one of the other major points that you made that is something I hear a lot when I’m talking to faculty in the U.S. or anywhere, and I might be saying, you know, you could try this or try this assignment or you could add this option, you could have this option. It’s just such a core principle is having options along with flexibility, but so but having those choices, I found has a little bit of a repercussion. Your research notes that too many options can often overwhelm the learners that carry the school trauma we already talked about, and thinking, what am I supposed to do? How? What is the right way? How do tutors find that sweet spot between the student agency and helpful structure? Because I have an answer, but I feel like it’s not the best answer. So I really want to pick your brain on this one. Yeah,
Caroline Brennan 23:38
I’m really excited to hear your answer, Dick. Yeah, but I suppose it’s one of those things where again, it’s why knowing your group is so important and what their capacity is. And I mentioned capacity earlier on, and that’s really what it comes down to, you know, because unconditional choice can actually overload the learner. Okay, especially if a learner is new and they’re used to that rigid kind of dictatorial school system of you know being told what to do and how to do it. You know, I’ve had a learner come in and they were very new, and you know, I was offering choice to learners and like, well, do you not know what to do? Like, they were really shocked that they were given choice, and you know, then you explain like, no, this is about you as an adult making your own decisions and using your voice and being able to, you know, stick up for yourself and do things in the best way that is possible for you. It doesn’t happen that often, but it does from time to time. So it really opens up that conversation. Um, so it really is about knowing your group, knowing where they’re at, knowing what their capacity is, and really, usually as a literacy tutor, you come in with plan A, B, C, and D. So even though they might have the illusion of choice, you’d kind of know what they’re going to choose as well. But what I would say is kind of the. Lower down they are in the scale of Bloom’s taxonomy, the less choice I would give them. So I might present things to them in a variety of ways. So they might not necessarily be saying, “Well, I want to listen to that, or I want to watch a video on that, or I want to have a discussion on that, or I want to write about that.” That will happen naturally throughout the course of the class itself, so I have made that decision for them. So everybody is receiving that information in a variety of ways. Right, that’s incredibly important for adult literacy because it’s providing variety through repetition. They need that repetition to to really grasp new concepts as well, and as well when we are assessing. So when they’re then sharing their knowledge, that they will write something to help with their writing skills. That they will say something to get it, you know, kind of clear in their mind first. Or they might record something, or they might, you know, draw a picture. Again, it’s that repetition. That the more repetition we can get into the class, the better it is for them. But but still not making it boring. So so that variety is essentially what what’s helping them. But really, it’s easier for us because with non-accredited courses, you have that space and that time. Yeah. And with the accredited courses, you are on a time frame, so you really have to co-create at the start. No, get to know your groups and maybe just ask them. You know, do a test exercise. How did you find that? Was it useful? Did you like it? Did you not? If they didn’t, we never do that in the class again. If they did, let’s do that for the next topic. Yeah. So it can be trial and error as well, but really, it’s not an endless platter of choice. It’s structured, you know. So you’re really scaffolding it for them.
Lillian Nave 26:44
Yeah. Oh. Okay. So first of all, that’s really one of the best answers I’ve ever heard for that question. Okay. I like your well. The the specifically that the lower level of the Bloom’s taxonomy is the less choice, and when we’re getting higher, then they’ve got more choices to do that, I’ve never heard that before. Okay, I’m taking that with me. I’m quoting you, Caroline Brennan, on that one. I’ll be using that when people ask, because I think that’s really good advice, and I hadn’t thought of that before. And when I am asked that question, I or I found out that what I had to do when I had learners that are first year students, and that’s what I teach at our university. is all first year students, and so they’re novices and they’re new to the university, and they want a lot of structure. They want the you know they what has been in high school for them, and you know the teacher is supposed to know exactly what they want, and if I don’t, then who does, right? Yeah, and that’s it can be overwhelming and confusing. And so, I what I came up with was you could do you know choice A, B, C, or D, or something else you want. You know, you you have a completely free choice in that. But if you want a preferred path. I’d say here’s the traditional, you know, assignment. If you, so I could say these are the preferred path, not my preferred, but it’s just sort of the preferred path. If you don’t want to make a decision, then you’re writing this essay and you’re creating a PowerPoint for this one and you’re doing that. So if you don’t want to make a decision and you kind of just want the the general, maybe what the original assignment was before I started making all of the options, I’ll say that’s the preferred path, and so it’s taking out that overwhelm or the choice. But then they can see it’s like, okay, well, I don’t love that preferred path. I could do, you know, option number two, but the rest of the stuff I’ll do the preferred path. That seems, you know, yeah. I think I’ll go along with that. That’s kind of the usual. I feel much more comfortable. That’s and that’s really what it is. They feel more comfortable doing maybe the more traditional assignment, and then if there’s one of those topics or areas or times in the semester where they think, oh, actually, I think I will try to make a infographic instead of you know write in my journal or something like that. I think I’ll try that this time. Then they they’re in that zone of proximal development. You know, they they can just hop into something that’s a little bit different rather than the you know the traditional way of doing it. So, but I I really feel like your answer is a lot better than mine. I don’t think so, but I
Caroline Brennan 29:30
actually really love that approach because you know especially when they’re starting out in first year, you know they probably do stick to the traditional route. But once they start to see their peers making different choices, yeah, you know, and to see how they’ve done it, it probably opens it up a little bit for them.
Lillian Nave 29:46
Yeah, that’s true, which is
Caroline Brennan 29:47
fantastic.
Lillian Nave 29:48
Yeah, along with that relational learning, you know, just like you’re in the weight room and you’re saying, “Oh, I didn’t know I could do that.” Exactly. Yeah, do it that way. Yeah. So, anyway. The I really appreciated that paying attention to that choice, you know, and and the feelings of the learner to be overwhelmed, and what can we do to help that? Because it’s often that we don’t, maybe we’re not tuned into that, and we can kind of just like when we give a syllabus at the beginning of the semester for talking about a college course, and it’s and they they see 28 different things, then I’m going to have to do all of this, and I have no idea how to do any of this. It can be overwhelming, yeah,
Caroline Brennan 30:34
absolutely. And I I think it’s one of the things that particularly adult literacy tutors are attuned to because even without realizing it, we’re always analyzing the learners and how are they doing and how are they faring with that particular thing and are they able for it or are they stuck or you know should I jump in or should I let them struggle that little bit more you know so so we are acutely aware of not overwhelming our learners because we want them to come back. Yes, we need to match them where they are at, and you know, I think slow is smooth, and smooth is fast. You know, and that’s really how we how we progress with them.
Lillian Nave 31:11
Yes, absolutely. Okay, and I also was blown away by something too that you you found in a pilot study. You said there were 38 out of 40 adult literacy students assessed turned out to be dyslexic in one of these. Yeah. So what does that tell us about how traditional schooling fails our students, our learners, and how can screening and UDL change that narrative?
Caroline Brennan 31:37
Okay. Well, I think any adult literacy tutor wasn’t blown away by that statistic because we see it every day in our classes. And usually, like neurodivergence doesn’t doesn’t happen by itself. It’s normally dyslexic, and they have dysgraphia, or they have ADHD, or they are autistic. And so, I think traditional schooling really requires conformity,
Lillian Nave 32:02
yes,
Caroline Brennan 32:02
and not just synchronous learning, but synchronous progress, and that’s not realistic for everyone. Okay, so one of the main classroom management strategies has been to mislabel learning differences as moral failings, behavioral issues, or in some cases, a lack of intelligence. Yeah, which is which is one of the kind of badges of shame that our adult literacy learners will wear coming in. You know that it’s their fault that they are not intelligent, and it’s nothing to do with intelligence whatsoever. Quite often, they are extremely bright. It’s just how they access Information, so I think because adult literacy tutors expect those learning differences, you know we are trained to expect it. We are trained to share information in different ways for them to express information in different ways. I think that’s why it overlaps with UDL so much. But I think in well, one of the recommendations that I made was that anyone who presents to an adult literacy service should be screened for dyslexia, and the reason is that if you can name it, if you can label it, it removes the blame from the person. It’s not that they couldn’t do it. That they have this learning a difference that they just need to be reached in a different way, and they then can be taught strategies and they can be taught ways of coping. And it doesn’t necessarily have to be the phonics race. It can be, you know, whatever way that suits them. You know, so and it’s it’s helping them to recognize that it’s not them that were the problem; that it was the environment that they were learning in.
Lillian Nave 33:48
Wow! Yeah, you’ve made my brain go a little crazy on that. Just thinking about all of those things, and specifically when you said it’s not just synchronous learning that we expect, but we expect synchronous progress.
Caroline Brennan 34:03
Yes,
Lillian Nave 34:05
that’s it’s so true. I hadn’t really thought about that. I’m thinking about maybe high school learners and math classes and things, and everybody has to be on the same page, literally and and figuratively. You know, after the first test, right, or by the first test, because then you have to do the second part by the second test, and
Caroline Brennan 34:28
absolutely,
Lillian Nave 34:28
you’ve got to get it done by October or whatever, you know.
Caroline Brennan 34:31
And if you didn’t get the first part, yeah, and you’re now on the third part, you’re in real trouble.
Lillian Nave 34:36
Yes, exactly. Wow, and we just that goes back to the very beginning of the system. System is not really built in a way that is accounting for that different rates of learning progress, right? And that’s not really helpful. And then that’s going to turn people. Out of the system, yeah. Until they come later and maybe get you know get to talk to somebody like you who understands why and how that system really failed the student. That the student didn’t fail math. The system failed the student.
Caroline Brennan 35:16
Absolutely.
Lillian Nave 35:17
Yeah. Hmm. That’s a lot to think about. Actually, that hits kind of close to home. Actually, for me, so this is a lot of good things to think about. Really, it’s a changing lens for for UDL practitioners. I think to be thinking about not just applying, you know, within our system, but what are the ways that we can really rethink those things. So you have a lot of research. It was. It’s a beautiful master thesis, I guess. Oh, thank you. And I encourage folks to to learn more about it. And there’s a lot. So if there’s one most important thing, or is there anything that you think is one or couple of the most important things that you want UDL practitioners, people like me who are now thinking, “Hmm, yeah, learning at the same rate.” That’s I can’t believe I’ve had that assumption, never even identified it. That so something you want UDL practitioners to take away from your research,
Caroline Brennan 36:21
okay. So I suppose I think that UDL and any form of teaching is most successful when you have a genuine connection with your learners, whatever way you can form that genuine connection. If you have bigger groups, just try different ways that work for you. I think it’s really important that we can’t allow educational institutions or policymakers to use UDL as a cost-cutting measure to dismantle specialized or community-based literacy services, especially literacy services, because they have been formed over decades of community practice. You know that there’s a real value to it there. I think, and I think that UDL is a fantastic framework for design, and we also need to meet educators where they are at, which is why, as we said, that plus one approach is so amazing. But we have to make sure that we are using UDL at the foundational level, so it’s really designing your curricula from the get-go with that UDL approach in mind. How do I reach my learners? How are my learners going to be able to express their learning? How will I know that they have learned? And it’s not that they produce the correct result; it’s that they have genuinely learned the skill,
Lillian Nave 37:42
right? Yeah, that’s a lot of backwards design. It’s
Caroline Brennan 37:46
yeah,
Lillian Nave 37:47
yeah. So it’s it’s really hard to let’s say okay, I’m gonna add UDL in the middle of my semester because you’ve already planned.
Caroline Brennan 37:56
Yeah,
Lillian Nave 37:56
you know, there’s some plus ones you can do. Like they’re definitely absolutely, and I say it all the time. Like you could do this tomorrow. You know, you you can add a different way for your learners to to accomplish something, but it’s not
Caroline Brennan 38:09
where you’re at.
Lillian Nave 38:10
Yeah, exactly. Start where you’re at. But to really to really make it work for everyone, then you really have to design. And I do say this a lot. So design from the beginning, but teaching is a lot of work, and there’s going to be times when students don’t understand the assignment, and so you’ve got to be working really hard with them and and meeting with students after class or whatever, and then you realize, okay, that wasn’t well designed, and so is your work going to be in the middle of the semester or the end when you’re trying to backtrack and figure out what went wrong, or is it going to be in the beginning of the semester where you try to, you know, clearly mark out flexibility and options and clarity and, you know, so there’s a lot of design work in the beginning or there’s a lot of makeup work in the middle, in the end. So, like, where do you? When do you want to be doing the work? You know, it’s you’re making yourself. You know, it’s just like organizing, putting out my clothes the night before, so I know what I’m wearing.
Caroline Brennan 39:13
There’s going to be work either way. When do you want to do it? Exactly,
Lillian Nave 39:16
exactly that kind of thing. Well, this is really a lovely conversation. It’s really fantastic to to be thinking about. Really, I can see the care that you have for the the learners that you work with for adult literacy, and you’ve really done an amazing brain work here on your master’s thesis. So I hope more people will be able to to take a look at it.
Caroline Brennan 39:41
Yeah, absolutely. Um, I can send you a link. I have
Lillian Nave 39:45
perfect
Caroline Brennan 39:45
published it on a website, so you can pop that into the show notes. If anyone is interested in reading, you’re very welcome to.
Lillian Nave 39:52
That’s great. I will. I’ll put it in our resources, and you’ve also got a couple really great UDL multiple means of representation because you have a. Other charts and yes, yes, things that go not just the written part. And now you’ve got a podcast on it too. So true, super beautiful gamut. That’s right, that’s right. So, well, thank you so much, Caroline, for joining me. I really appreciate it.
Caroline Brennan 40:15
Thank you for having me.
Lillian Nave 40:17
It’s been really great. Thanks. Thank you for listening to this episode of the Think UDL podcast. New episodes are posted on social media on LinkedIn, Facebook, X, and Blue Sky. You can find transcripts and resources pertaining to each episode on our website, Think udl.org. The music in each episode is created by the Oddyssey Quartet. Oddyssey is spelled with two Ds, by the way, comprised of Rex Shepherd, David Pate, Bill Folwell, and Jose Cochez. I’m your host Lillian Nave, and I want to thank Appalachian State University for helping to support this podcast. And if you call it appellation, I’ll throw an apple at you. Thank you for joining. I’m your host, Lillian Nave. Thanks for listening to the Think UDL podcast.
